Banana Creme Pie Pop Tarts Review

Going along with the recent cake, pie, and cobbler flavor trend Pop Tarts has going on lately, we are here today to tell you about Banana Creme Pie Pop Tarts.

Do they taste like their namesake dessert? Are they worth buying? We will answer these questions and more in our Banana Creme Pie Pop Tarts Review!

Banana Cream Pie Pop Tarts Review

Well, they definitely smell like Pop Tarts with an added banana fragrance. However, we would never guess that the Pop Tarts in this picture are banana creme pie flavored without seeing the box for ourselves.

banana creme pie pop tarts review inside picture

Despite the overall beige and brown colors that give off graham cracker vibes, this pastry is a sweet flavor party-in-your-mouth with notes of banana, vanilla, and graham cracker crumbs. The banana flavor is milder than we would prefer, but at least they manage to get the taste of cream pie in there.

One reviewer summed up our thoughts perfectly, “It’s good, but I think it would be better with a banana pudding-like center mixed with whatever that is in the middle.”

If you like want a sweet flavor that is more cream pie than banana, you need to try Banana Cream Pie Pop Tarts. Otherwise, this is a nice flavor, but not the best Pop Tarts flavor that we have ever eaten.

Summary and Rating

What’s up with all the beige and tan? We still don’t know. What we can tell you is there’s a surprising amount of cream pie flavor in Banana Creme Pie Pop Tarts and less banana than we expected.

See also  Smucker's Uncrustables Pizza Roll-Ups Review


  • Sweet cream pie flavor
  • Good cold or hot
  • Banana goes well in Pop Tarts


  • A bit light on banana flavor
  • Would be better with banana pudding in the middle

Rating: 7.2/10

Have you tried these yet? Do you agree with our Banana Creme Pie Pop Tarts Review? Please share your thoughts in the comments below!

(Visited 147 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Comment