Pumpkin Pie PopTarts Review

If you love traditional Fall flavors like pumpkin pie or pumpkin spice, then you might want to know more about Pumpkin Pie PopTarts. Pumpkin Pie is a limited edition flavor that is usually available in the Fall. It features the same pastry, icing, and sprinkles that PopTarts are known for with a festive pumpkin pie filling that contains real cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg.

Do they taste like real pumpkin pie? We are here to answer this question and more in our review of Pumpkin Pie PopTarts!

Pumpkin Pie PopTarts Review

These feel like an upgraded version of regular PopTarts, with their festive sprinkles and slight pumpkin spice scent. The sprinkle colors remind us of autumn leaves!

Pumpkin Pie PopTarts Review

As far as the flavor goes, it is not quite pumpkin pie. In order to truly taste like pumpkin pie it would need more pumpkin flavor and a bit more sweetness in the filling. What this flavor does do well is provide pumpkin spice notes. There are prominent notes of both cinnamon and clove with just a hint of pumpkin flavor. We all agree that a more fitting name for this variety would be ‘Pumpkin Spice PopTarts’.

The spice flavor does mellow out a bit and allow for more pumpkin-like flavor when these PopTarts are warm. Although they may not be true to their namesake in flavor, Pumpkin Pie PopTarts are a nice change of pace from fruity and chocolaty flavors and easily put us in a Fall mood. Pumpkin spice fans are sure to love them!

Summary And Review

The pumpkin spice flavor is definitely present, while the pumpkin is more muted than the name ‘Pumpkin Pie PopTarts’ would suggest.

See also  Crumbl Cookie Flavors For The Week Of May 1, 2023: Maple Oatmeal Cookies, Buckeye Brownie, and More!


  • Festive
  • Sweet
  • Strong cinnamon and clove flavors


  • Little actual pumpkin flavor
  • More like pumpkin spice than pumpkin pie

All of our reviewers agree that these are perfect if you love pumpkin spice, but may not be for those looking for a strong pumpkin flavor.

Rating: 7.25/10

What do you think of Pumpkin Pie PopTarts? Let us know in the comments below 🙂

(Visited 76 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Comment